At a glance
- How Brighton’s recruitment system works?
- Is it sustainable without success?
- Where do Brighton go next?
Brighton currently sit in sixth, eight points behind Aston Villa and in a Europa League spot. Their rise to being a Premier League top 10 team is nothing short spectacular. Since returning to the topflight in 2017, progress has been steady. Since the 2021-22 season, they have been inside the top 10 three seasons out of four, and this one looks like adding to that list.
So How Have They Done It?
This has not been an easy fix. It has been years of careful planning, data-led decisions, and a value-led philosophy which has prioritized development, and cultural fit over big-name signings. It’s almost a Moneyball concept to football transfers – under-the-radar signings that scouts and clubs overlook.
This method relies on detailed data analysis, with rigorous scouting of the lesser-known leagues across the world. It also relies on early investment in player potential over reputation.
Brighton signed players like Ben White from Southampton’s youth academy on a free transfer for their U18 side and later sold him to Arsenal for €58.5 million as pure profit. They also developed another academy player, Robert Sanchez, before selling him to Chelsea for €23 million.
Brighton’s Transfer Strategy: Player Trading Breakdown (2017–Present)
Here is a table of players who Brighton bought and sold since becoming a Premier League side.
| Player | Bought for | Sold for |
| Moises Caicedo | €28.2 million | €116 million |
| Marc Cucurella | €18 million | €65.3 million |
| Leandro Trossard | €15.56 million | €24 million |
| Dan Burn | €3.55 million | €15 million |
| Alexis Mac Allister | €8 million | €42 million |
| Yves Bissouma | €16.8 million | €29.2 million |
| Joao Pedro | €34.2 million | €63.7 million |
| Simon Adringa | €8 million | €24.4 million |
| Pervis Estupinan | €17.8 million | €17 million |
| Billy Gilmour | €8.3 million | €14.75 million |
| Valentin Barco | €9.15 million | €10 million |
| Deniz Undav | €7 million | €26.7 million |
| TOTALS | €174.56 million | €448.05 million |
Table 1- information from transfermarkt.co.uk
This highlights some of Brighton’s most expensive transfers and how the club has invested in key players over time.
In just those 12 players, there is a massive €273.49 million profit. Obviously, there are other players who have been bought and sold, and that figure does not include €81.5 million profit from the two Academy players. However, the best bit of business is probably Pascal Gross – Originally bought for €3 million, sold for €7 million and then bought again for €2 million.
Brighton’s Transfer Spending vs Income by Season (Premier League Era)
To show how much they have spent on players and received back from departures, take a look at this table. Again, this is just from their time in the Premier League.
| Season | Arrivals | Departures |
| 2017/2018 | €70 million | €400k |
| 2018/2019 | €90.62 million | €13.62 million |
| 2019/2020 | €61.74 million | €8.5 million |
| 2020/2021 | €50.10 million | €20.60 million |
| 2021/2022 | €75.58 million | €78.8 million |
| 2022/2023 | €55.7 million | €138.4 million |
| 2023/2024 | €106.85 million | €189 million |
| 2024/2025 | €281.45 million | €50.74 million |
| 2025/2026 | €82 million | €145.1 million |
| TOTALS | €874.04 million | €645.16 million |
Table 2information from transfermarkt.co.uk
So, according to these figures, Brighton have actually made a €228.88 million loss. These figures include players that at still at the club, like Adam Webster (brought from Bristol City for €22.22 million) and players that were bought for big money and sold for a lot less, like Jakob Moder (signed from Lech Poznan for €11 million but sold to Feyenoord for €1.5 million).
Is it Sustainable for Success?
What is success for Brighton? Well, when they come up in 2017/18, it would be survival until established. Once they became established, what next? Mid-table? They are certainly doing that at the moment. Is it European football – They have achieved that by getting to the round of 16 and getting beat by Roma over the two legs in the UEFA Europa League in 2023/24 season.
Is the next step breaking into the top four and Champions League? If that’s the case, then sitting in fifth place gives them Champions League football next season, should they stay in that spot. If not, then European football in the form of the Europa League or even the Conference League would be a successful season, wouldn’t it?
Where do Brighton go Next?
Again, that depends on the definition of success. Constantly playing European Football, maybe winning domestic trophies – that would the next logical step up, but for now, I would suggest they keep doing what they are doing – finding talent that others miss, or developing younger talent through their academy system, and then who knows what the future brings – Premier League trophy, maybe even a Champions League trophy – Brighton supporters have every right to dream with how Tony Bloom and Paul Barber are running the club.
Keep up to date with all of the Brighton & Hove Albion news content with Read Brighton.
